Usually the films I examine in the "Movies with Alabama Connections" series are fictional, but this one is a "documentary" short made during World War II. I ran across it recently and thought it featured several interesting elements. The film was released in 1942 by the Agricultural Adjustment Agency, U.S. Department of Agriculture. Created during the New Deal, the agency promoted modern agricultural methods and agriculture's importance to the nation. Henry Browne, Farmer was nominated for a Documentary Academy Award in 1943.
In its nearly eleven minute running time, the film has three parts. The first is a brief opening that sets the context of agriculture's importance to the nation's effort in World War II. We see marching soldiers, tanks, a scene in a factory. Then the narrator tells us agricultural production is just as vital. The second, main section depicts a day in the lives of Henry Browne and his family on the farm. Finally, we see the family make a special visit to Tuskegee.
Below are some screen shots and further comments. This film, along with three earlier ones from the Agriculture Department dealing with African-Americans, are given extensive analysis in J. Emmett Winn's 2012 book, Documenting Racism: African Americans in US Department of Agriculture Documentaries, 1921-42 [Continuum, 2012]. You can find the detailed chapter on Henry Browne, Farmer and the rest of the book here.
Winn notes, "As with the other films addressed in this book, the filmmakers constructed a reality that informs and persuades the audience to understand and accept the content as accurate and believable. Henry Browne accomplishes these goals by showing the Brownes as they go about their lives on the farm; segments include the introduction of the members of the Browne family and their farm, the family eating a nutritious breakfast, the merits of the family garden, the importance of raising livestock, the preventive maintenance and reusing of materials, and the careful use of the land. Each of these segments demonstrates that the Brownes are model farmers who utilize the best judgment and practices in managing their farm and home." He also observes that unlike the other agency films about African-Americans, the race of the Brownes is never mentioned.
Despite the realism, the family is apparently fictional. No one is named except the father and his son Henry Jr. The individuals playing the father, mother, children and older brother may have been Macon County residents, but are not credited in the film. I presume the Agricultural Adjustment Agency would not have had the budget to bring in actors from elsewhere. I did not find a Henry Browne and family in the 1930 or 1940 U.S. Census for Macon County.
In the final pages of his chapter, Winn addresses the ultimate irony of Henry Browne, Farmer. "The Brownes live in a black America that is separate from white America, and the film suggests that the situation is not just okay; it is good. I argue that the film is deceptive in its support of the doctrine of separate-but-equal Jim Crow racism. The Brownes thrive in a racially separate world where everything is not only going well but also improving. In the last year the Brownes have improved their meals, livestock, and crops. In comparison with the other USDA films about rural black populations, Henry Browne presents favorable conditions for African American farmers in Alabama." The Browne family seems to exist in its own successful world outside the realities of segregation and the real status of blacks in America at the time.
The film was a success in that it was shown to many black audiences around the country by extension agents and distributed to some 500 theaters by Republic Pictures. Walter White, who was Executive Secretary of the NAACP for many years, wrote to the Agriculture Department praising the work. You can watch the film at the U.S. Library of Congress' web site.
Northwest Enterprise [Seattle] 30 December 1942
